












The controversy began as soon as I opened my mouth about
Laduree.
I was recounting my London Princess Week (see UK 1 post) to sis, Chanel, who, as soon as I hit the
Harrods Laduree Cafe, almost exploded with excitement..."There's a new macaroon in town. Better than Laduree."
Hmmmmmm....I thought. Better than Laduree??? Doubtful.
I mean, how on earth can anything be better than those delicate morsels of crunchy-on-the-outside-gooey-on-the-inside macaroons sandwiched together with voluptuous ganaches?? After all, Laduree is the founder of this very special "double-decker" type of macaroon.
Now, Chanel is a woman of fine taste - she really does know her stuff - so an investigation of this "newbie",
Pierre Herme was in order. Pierre Herme has only one location in the UK, in the foodhall at
Selfridges. Selfridges is a very very fine department store in the UK - modern and oh-so-chic! I know the foodhalls well...so off I went, hunting.
OH MY.
OH DOUBLE MY.
I'll stop us here sportsfans to explain the pics above. Pic 1 and 2 are the famous Laduree macaroons. Pics 3 & 4 are the new-kids-on-the-block, Pierre Herme
macarons (yep, these guys use the french word, macarons - only one "o" - very posh!).
Both brands look beautiful, both packagings are beautiful, but right off the bat I detected a difference. Looking at packaging, shop layout and flavour offerings, it was clear that Laduree takes a very traditional approach, while the Pierre Herme is a more modern, almost sexier version of the
macaron!
I taste-tested the Pierre Herme (PH for short) back at Chanel's pad, and they were utterly divine. Nothing says it better than their own little "menu",
"A thin, crisp shell, circular in shape, lightly rounded, with tempting colours and a tender interior...That will leave your senses quivering with pleasure".
QUIVERING WITH PLEASURE!
I quivered.
With flavours like
Fragola (macaron biscuit, balsamic vinegar cream, strawberry compote),
Huile d'Olive & Vanille (macaron biscuit, olive oil cream and vanilla), and
Jasmin (macaron biscuit, jasmine flower and jasmine tea cream)...the Mmmmmms in the house were getting a little out of hand. The olive oil and vanilla one just blew me away, you could actually sense the rustic olive oil flavour rather than taste it...it was like nothing I've had before.
So. Chanel was right. Pierre Herme were good. Very good. But, were they better than Laduree????
I decided the only way to really answer that question was a blind taste-test.
A Macaroon-Off was planned.
Meanwhile, while all this macaroon action was going on, Chanel and I had actually booked in for a macaroon cooking class at
L'atelier des Chefs (my third class there!). What a coincidence! The pictures above show you our journey from having no idea how these mighty morsels were made...to Chanel producing the best ones of the day!
Chef James, ex Head Pastry Chef at the Mandarin Oriental in London, taught us how to make 4 different types of macaroons. I attempted the
Lime macaroon with Ginger and Lime Cream, and Chanel went for the very very pretty, and highly sought after
Macaroon with Raspberry and Pistachio Cream. There was also
Chocolate and Coconut Macaroons produced, and the rather wacky
Apricot and Lavender Macaroon.
One of my fave pics there above is the table with all the raw macaroons "drying" - (just like nail polish) you have to "set" the raw macaroons to reduce cracking in the oven - cool hey! The other favourite is Chanel and I showing our very mature approach to the oh-so-serious art of macaroon making! And you can't go past Chanel, there, proudly displaying her "Teacher's Pet" macaroon ability!! A+ Chanel.
So, we were now well informed on the art of baking the macaroon. With the cooking class under our belt, and our tastebuds ready to go, we were all set for our Macaroon-Off.
The Macaroon-Off process was simple. I went to both Laduree and Pierre Herme within 30 mins of each other. I purchased a Rose, Chocolate, and Lemon macaroon from each (it had to be a like-for-like taste test). After dinner, Geeko (Chanel's hubby) was brought in to administer the test - he had to cut each macaroon in half, and feed them to us flavour by flavour (we were blindfolded - final pic above) and keep score. Our scoring process was simple, we just had to decide which we liked the best for each flavour.
We took our jobs very seriously, but even so, it was a total hoot. Being blindfolded had it's usual comic relief, but it also allowed you to fully concentrate on the flavour.
And the results? Well they were interesting.
It was a closer race than either of us expected. It was clear that the textures of each was a point of difference - the Laduree have a thinner biscuit with more "crunch" on the outside, while PH still had a crunch, but the biscuit was thicker and a bit gooeyer (is that a word?). The cream or ganache was thicker in the PH. But what about the flavour? Well we were torn on that, Chanel clearly liked the PH for flavour, whereas I, according to Geeko, "was all over the place"!
After great discussion, both Chanel and I came to the same conclusion. If we were having guests and were going to serve the best macaroons available, we would go for.......
DRUM ROLL PLEASE....Pierre Herme.
Yes, Pierre Herme wins the inaugural Macaroon-Off, or should I now say
Macaron-Off!!
Chanel, of course, was right!